Using a real world situation to understand theories

To help you better understand the theories, we will apply them to a real-world ongoing situation between India, Pakistan, and to a lesser degree, China, over the region of Kashmir.  Please read the background information below then follow each of the highlighted links to read more about recent situation Kashmir. 

It might help you to refer to the chart on the theories as you think about how a realist, liberal, or Marxist would view what is happening in this region and between these countries. 

Some of the things you want to think about are:

1)  Why is there a conflict over the region of Kashmir?  What is the history of the conflict?

2)  What are the key aspects of the conflict for each of these theories?  Is it about power? Religion? Money? what? 

3)  What are the key interests at stake for India and Pakistan?  How might Kashmir be divided

4)  How does the situation affect the people and their livelihoods (Bus service and Tourists flock back to Kashmir)?
 

Background*

Ever since the partition of the sub-continent in 1947, when Britain dismantled its Indian empire, India and Pakistan have been arch rivals. The animosity has its roots in religion and history, and is epitomised by the long-running conflict over the state of Jammu and Kashmir. This has recently escalated into a dangerous nuclear arms race.

The Indian subcontinent was partitioned into Hindu-dominated but nominally secular India and the newly created Muslim state of Pakistan after India’s independence from Great Britain in 1947. Severe rioting and population movement ensued and an estimated half a million people were killed in communal violence. About a million people were left homeless. Since partition, the territory of Jammu and Kashmir has remained in dispute, with Pakistan and India both holding sectors.

1947-1948 War- India and Pakistan first went to war in October 1947 after Pakistan supported a Muslim insurgency in Kashmir. India agreed to a request for armed assistance from Kashmir's Maharaja, in return for accession of the state to India. But the nature of that accession has long been the subject of debate. The war ended on 1 January 1949, with the establishment of a ceasefire line. The status of the territory remained in dispute because an agreed referendum to confirm the accession was never held.

1965 War-The two countries went to war again after Pakistan launched a covert offensive across the ceasefire line into Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir. India retaliated by crossing the international border at Lahore.

1971 War (not over Kashmir)-Pakistan descended into civil war after East Pakistan demanded autonomy and later independence. India invaded East Pakistan in support of its people after millions of civilians fled to India. At the end of 1971, Bangladesh was created out of East Pakistan.

1989- Armed resistance to Indian rule broke out in the Kashmir valley in 1989, with some groups calling for independence and others calling for union with Pakistan. India accused Pakistan of supplying weapons to the militants. During the 1990s, with the emergence of militant Muslim groups, the movement’s ideology became essentially Islamic in nature.

1996-1997- India and Pakistan set up low-level meetings to defuse tension over Jammu and Kashmir. The diplomatic push became more concerted a year later and an agenda for peace talks was agreed on. Also in 1997, Pakistan suggested that the two sides meet to discuss restraining nuclear and missile capabilities.

1998- Fears of a nuclear confrontation grew, after both sides conducted nuclear tests. The US ordered sanctions against both countries, with several European nations doing the same. Tensions were reduced early the following year after the two sides signed an accord pledging to intensify efforts to resolve all issues – including that of Jammu and Kashmir.

1999-Kargil Conflict- Conflict again erupted after India launched air strikes against Pakistani-backed forces that had infiltrated Indian-administered Kashmir. Fighting built up towards a direct conflict between the two states and tens of thousands of people were reported to have fled their homes on both sides of the ceasefire line. Later that year, General Musharraf led a military coup in Pakistan.

2001- Tension along the ceasefire line continued. In October 38 people were killed after an attack on the Kashmiri assembly in Srinagar. A month later, 14 people were killed in an attack on the Indian parliament in Delhi. India again blamed Pakistani-backed Kashmiri militants. A dramatic build up of troops along the Indo-Pakistan border ensued.

March 18, 2008- At least 12 people are hurt by a large blast in central Srinagar, the main city in Indian-administered Kashmir.  Reports say a long-running dispute over property may have led to the killing. Police say a property dealer has been arrested in connection with the assassination of an Indian anti-terrorism police official.  Four days later, military troops raided a Pakistan-based Islamist militant hideout in connection with the bombing.

*(Excerpts taken from BBC News' India-Pakistan Timeline http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/static/in_depth/south_asia/2002/india_pakistan/timeline/default.stm)

Additional Links

Violence Threatens Kashmir Peace

Rivals Row over Kashmir Ceasefire

India and Pakistan Resume Talks

Muslim Anger over Kashmir Deal

Several Die in Kashmir Violence

Kashmir Shutdown to Mark UN Day